Jump to content

Talk:Q1037

Add topic
From Wikidata

circular reference

[edit]

Q1037 has a P17 property to Q1037 . This happens also for P1246.

I don't know why only these 2 countries (according to my bot) have a circular reference.

If it is a mistake, please correct it (I don't know how...)

I guess this should be forbidden by a rule . Goulu (talk) 05:30, 14 August 2024 (UTC)Reply

Harmonizing Rwanda’s location description (Q1037)

[edit]

There are inconsistencies in the way Rwanda (Q1037) is described and categorized:

  • In some language descriptions, Rwanda is simply "sovereign state in Africa."
  • In others, it is described as "sovereign state in Central Africa."
  • The "located in/on physical feature" (P706) statements also sometimes classify Rwanda under *Central Africa* rather than *East Africa*.

This is problematic because major international sources consistently place Rwanda in **East Africa**, not Central Africa:

  • African Union (AU): Rwanda is a member of the East African Community (EAC).
  • United Nations geoscheme: Rwanda is in the Eastern Africa subregion.
  • World Bank: Lists Rwanda under East Africa.

Proposal

[edit]
  • Harmonize all descriptions so that they read: "country in East Africa."
  • Update P706 (located in/on physical feature) to reflect East Africa as the primary region.
  • Optionally retain regional groupings like "Great Lakes region" as secondary classifications.
  • Ensure consistency across language versions to avoid confusion in re-use (e.g., Wikipedia infoboxes, Google Knowledge Panels).

This change would make the item more accurate, reduce ambiguity, and align with authoritative sources. Irifasum (talk) 17:13, 2 October 2025 (UTC)Reply